- $39.99 Funko Pocket Pop! Supernatural Keychains Dean+Castiel with wings+Sam NEW
- $35.00 Culturefly Warner Brothers Supernatural Figures- Dean, Sam, Casiel & Crowley Set
- $185.00 1/6 scale SUPERNATURAL RUBY Genevieve Padalecki 12" Action Figure w/DEMON KNIFE
- $156.64 Charlie Bradbury 176 ~ Supernatural ~ Funko Pop Vinyl ~ NEAR MINT + PROTECTOR
- $9.99 Warner Brothers Figural Bag Clip Series 1 Supernatural Dean Winchester
- $29.95 1986 Tonka Super Naturals MR LUCKY Heroic Ghostling Factory Sealed Blister Pack
- $300.00 QMX Supernatural Dean Winchester 1/6 collectible figure
- $200.00 OOAK Supernatural Dean Winchester 12 inch Articulated Action Figure Collectible
- $17.99 Coach Dean Q-Pals Plush [New ]
- $15.00 Vintage 80's Supernaturals Glow in the Dark Ghostling Sword Toy 1987
- $9.99 Funko Supernatural Mystery Mini Figure CROWLEY 1/12
- $29.99 Marvel Universe Super Naturals Venom 10” Action Figure 1999 Toy Biz OPEN ITEM
- $89.99 QMx SUPERNATURAL Join the Hunt Mini Masters DEAN WINCHESTER 5" Figure Statue
- $179.99 Lot of 3 SilverHawks Copper Kid, Bluegrass & Super Naturals Skull Action Figures
- $40.00 Supernatural Collectible Vinyl Figure 4.5″Culturefly Exclusive – Dean Winchester
- $45.00 Rags Evil Ghostling Super Naturals Holographic Action Figure Tonka 1987 Complete
- $100.00 Vintage 1987 Tonka Super Naturals Snakebite Evil Warrior Hologram MOC
- $8.96 Burnheart 1987 Tonka Super Naturals Evil Warrior Hologram Mint Figure No L Arm
- $43.19 Vintage Tonka Super Naturals Hooter Ghostling Figure rare
- $27.90 TONKA Super Naturals Mr. Lucky Heroic Ghostling Figurine NIB
- $14.99 1986 Tonka Super Naturals Evil Ghostling "Rags" Egyptian Mummy ~ SHELL ONLY
- $40.00 1/12 Supernatural Head Hero Set Sculpt for 7" Painted Mcfarlane Neca Winchesters
- $85.00 Vtg Super Naturals Dark Dragon Tonka 1987 Htf Evil Battle Beast Fits Motu
- $79.99 Funko Pop Supernatural Sam 93 & Dean 94 2 Pops HTF Ships w/ HOLDERS
- $20.00 Funko Pop! Television Supernatural Join The Hunt #200 Crowley
- $200.00 OOAK Supernatural Sam Winchester 12 inch Articulated Action Figure Collectible
- $3.00 Super Naturals LIONHEART Action Figure Tonka 1987 BROKEN ARM Missing
- $22.49 Quantum Mechanix Coach Dean Q-Pal Plush Figure
- $202.89 Funko POP! Television - Supernatural Vinyl Figure - BOBBY SINGER #305 *NON-MINT*
- $34.59 Crowley 200 ~ Supernatural ~ Funko Pop Vinyl + FREE POP PROTECTOR
- $199.99 Supernatural Join The Hunt Dean Winchester Mini Masters Figure QMX New in Box
- $224.75 Tonka Supernaturals Action Figure Toy hologram Super Naturals MOC Lionheart Lion
- $14.99 Funko Supernatural Mystery SAM WINCHESTER Mini Figure BLOODY Variant
- $10.45 Supernaturals Snakebite Vintage 1987 M 6" Action Figure 80's
- $150.00 Tonka Supernaturals Action Figure Toy hologram Super Naturals MOC Burnheart
- $250.00 1987 Super Naturals Dark Dragon Evil Battle Beast Tonka COMPLETE RARE!!!!
- $129.99 Tonka Supernaturals Lionheart Action Figure hologram Super Naturals NEW
- $29.95 1999 Toy Biz Marvel Universe Super Naturals "VENOM" 10" Action Figure in Box
- $19.95 Niffler Fantastic Beasts Harry Potter Q-Pals Q-Pal Plush Figure Quantum Mechanix
- $39.99 VTG Marvel Universe 10” CARNAGE Super Naturals Poseable Toy Biz Marvel Comics
- $120.00 Dean Winchester -Supernatural - Join The Hunt - Mini Masters - QMX Figure - NEW
- $40.00 SUPERNATURAL DEAN and SAM 2 Figure Set CW TV SHOW 1/24 Scale 3D Printed
- $9.95 Vintage Tonka 1987 Super Naturals Lionheart Sword Accessory Part
- $16.99 Coach Dean Q-Pals Plush [New ]
- $17.99 Funko Supernatural Mystery Mini Thin Man Figure 1/24 RARE thinman
- $166.90 1/6 Scale Custom SCARECROW figure Horror Supernatural Demon Monster
- $28.00 Vintage Super Naturals Ghostling Hooter Action Figure 1987 Tonka
- $29.95 1999 Toy Biz Marvel Universe Super Naturals "Spider-Man" Action Figure in Box
- $38.00 Supernatural Join the Hunt Castiel "Steve" Funko Pop! #304 Hot Topic Exclusive
- $38.50 Castiel Wings Supernatural Q-Pal Plush Figure Quantum Mechanix Qmx
- $24.95 Vintage 1986 Tonka Super Naturals Weird Wolf Evil Hologram Toy & Mini Comic Book
- $69.99 Vintage 1987 Tonka SUPER NATURALS Lionheart Snakebite Thunderbolt w/ Accessories
- $49.99 Tonka Super Naturals Action Figure Spooks Heroic Ghostling 1987 New Sealed
- $7.00 132 SAM WINCHESTER - custom resin headcast
- $10.49 Supernatural Join The Hunt Crowley Voodoo String Doll
- $64.99 Dean WINCHESTER - SUPERNATURAL - Join The Hunt - Mini Masters - QMX Figure - NEW
- $14.00 Vintage Super Naturals: Snakebite, Eagle Eye Figure, Lionheart Shield 1987 Tonka
- $325.99 Funko SUPERNATURAL Convention Exclusive Lot! BLOODY SAM+ DEAN + CROWLEY!
- $19.49 NWT Quantum Mechanix Coach Dean Winchester Supernatural Q-Pal Plush Figure
- $25.00 1987 Tonka Super Naturals Eagle Eye Action Figure With Shield B
- $29.99 Super Naturals "Lion Wings" Tonka 1987) NOT COMPLETE
- $22.99 Lionheart Super Naturals Parts - Shield & Mask 1987 Vintage Original 37d2
- $22.95 Burnheart 1987 Tonka Super Naturals Evil Warrior Hologram Action Figure
- $140.97 Custom Made SUPERNATURAL Three sided Angel Blade
- $39.99 FUNKO POP POCKET KEYCHAIN LOT DEAN SAM CASTIEL + EXCLUSIVE
- $24.99 1987 Tonka Super Naturals Eagle Eye Action Figure Head Dress & Chest Armor C
- $34.99 FUNKO POP! TELEVISION SUPERNATURAL - #95 CASTIEL WITH WINGS Great Condition NIB
- $99.95 Vintage SUPERNATURALS GHOST FINDER Vehicle 1987 Tonka Hot Rod Action Figure Car
- $25.00 1987 Tonka Super Naturals Eagle Eye Action Figure With Head Dress a
- $150.00 Funko Pop supernatural Crowley w/Bloody Face #200 Convention Exclusive
- $277.38 Crowley Metallic Blood Splatter With Sticker Funko Pop Vinyl EXPERT PACKAGING
- $7.00 131 DEAN WINCHESTER JENSEN ACKLES - custom resin headcast
- $42.00 Vintage Toy Lot 1991 TROMA Toxic Crusaders Watch ~ 1987 Super Naturals & Troll
- $45.00 Vtg 1980's Action Figure lot Robocop Wrestling Ghostbusters MOTU Super Naturals
- $10.00 Lionheart Super Naturals Parts - Shield & Mask 1987 Vintage Original
- $45.00 Custom 1/6 Supernatural Sam amd Dean Winchester heads hand painted
- $20.89 Painted 1/18 Supernatural Sam Head Sculpt Man Head Model For 3.75" Action Figure
- $69.99 SAM WINCHESTER - SUPERNATURAL - Join The Hunt - Mini Masters - QMX Figure - NEW
- $45.69 Sam (Metallic Bloody) 93 ~ Supernatural ~ Funko Pop Vinyl 2013 Authentic (Open)
- $99.90 SAM WINCHESTER - SUPERNATURAL - Join The Hunt - Mini Masters - QMX Figure - NEW
- $73.89 Funko POP! Supernatural Vinyl Figure - SAM (FBI Suit) #93 (Exclusive) *NON-MINT*
- $30.00 rare GI JOE Convention EXCLUSIVE 12 INCH GI JOE prototype?
- $10.00 Eagle Eye Chief Super Naturals 1987 Tonka Vintage Action Figure Indian rare C5
- $14.95 Vintage Tonka 1987 Super Naturals Lionheart Face Shield Mask Accessory Part
- $25.00 Dean Winchester Action Figure Supernatural Culturefly Vinyl Figure with Base NIB
- $13.03 FUNKO DORBZ SUPERNATURAL DEAN #76 VINYL FIGURE + FREE PROTECTOR
- $15.99 Supernatural SDCC Exclusive "Swan Song" Diecast Metallica Impala
- $10.49 Supernatural Join The Hunt CASTIEL Voodoo String Doll
- $20.89 Funko Pocket POP! Keychain - Supernatural - CASTIEL (1.5 inch) *NON-MINT*
- $7.59 Super Naturals Skull skeleton SuperNaturals Tonka action figure 1980s Vintage
- $12.75 Supernaturals Eagle Eye Shield 1987 Tonka
- $24.99 SUPER NATURALS Mini-Comic #1 - Tonka Hologram Vintage Toy 1987 SPANISH Rare NM
- $13.99 Super Naturals Lionheart Mask 1987 Tonka Part
- $34.14 Funko Dorbz: Supernatural Castiel Action Figure Design/Style may Vary
- $17.50 Hellspawn Demon Goat Onyx & Ruby Colored 3D PRINTED & HAND PAINTED
- $22.99 Supernatural Collectible Vinyl Figure 4.5″Culturefly Exclusive – Dean Winchester
- $35.69 Vintage Tonka Super Naturals Figures Parts Lot Lionheart burnheart Shield
- $11.99 Funko Mystery Minis Vinyl Figure: Supernatural - Kevin Tran + Lilith Bloody
- $15.19 Unpainted 1/18 Supernatural Jensen Man Head Sculpt For 3.75" Action Figure
- $64.61 Supernatural Sam Blood Splatter Exclusive Pop! Vinyl Figure #93