- $179.95 Lot of 12 McFarlane's SportsPicks, NFL John Elway, Steve McNair, Peyton Manning+
- $274.99 SLU Custom Colts Box Legends Peyton Manning Unitas Faulk Dickerson Faulk Frame
- $99.00 Peyton Manning McFarlane NFL Figure 12" WHITE VARIANT 🔥🔥🔥 RARE
- $50.00 2007 Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts 9" Gladiators of the Gridiron Figure #18
- $10.00 Peyton Manning Vs Eli Manning 2004 McFarlane X-SportsPicks 2 Pack Of Figures
- $79.99 QB Legacy Archi Peyton Eli Manning Figure Set MISB McFarlane Toys 2009
- $79.95 NFL Re-Plays Series 3 Manning Vs Manning Figure Gracelyn 2008 Strahan Harrison
- $21.98 2002 McFarlane Sportspicks | NFL Indianapolis Colts | Peyton Manning | Figure
- $38.00 1994 DENNIS RODMAN San Antonio Spurs scarce Red hair *FREE_s/h* Starting Lineup
- $4.99 1988-2001 Starting Lineup SLU Figures & Card Lot Baseball Basketball Football RC
- $21.99 McFarlane 2010 Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts NFL series 24 (rare piece)
- $20.00 2002 McFarlane Sportspicks NFL Indianapolis Colts Peyton Manning Figure
- $25.99 NEW IN BOX McFarlane Toys Peyton Manning and Eli Manning Deluxe Two Pack
- $230.00 MCFARLANE NFL SERIES 21, 12 FIGURE LOT BASE+VARIANT SET ROGERS, WARNER, NEW
- $34.79 Peyton Manning Denver Playmakers White 4” McFarlane Broncos NEW
- $34.99 McFarlane NFL Series 30 PEYTON MANNING Action Figure NIB - Broncos | Colts
- $24.72 PEYTON MANNING #18 Bleacher Creatures 15" inch Plush Doll Indianapolis Colts NFL
- $16.99 Peyton Manning QB Indianapolis Colts McFarlane NFL Sports Picks Series 4
- $29.99 MCFARLANE NFL SUPER BOWL XLIV (44) SAINTS VS. COLTS MANNING ADDAI HOF DIORAMA!!!
- $39.99 MCFARLANE NFL INDIANAPOLIS COLTS PEYTON MANNING HOF TWO (2) ACTION FIGURES NEW!
- $29.99 MCFARLANE NFL 34 PEYTON MANNING BRONCOS WHITE JERSEY CHASE FIGURE /1500
- $33.00 2009 McFarlane Toys College Football Peyton Manning #93294 New
- $12.99 2002 McFarlane NFL Series 4 Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts New In Package S2
- $14.98 1999 Kenner Starting Lineup Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Action Figure New
- $65.00 NFL McFarlane Steelers Ben Roethlisberger Series 28 675 of 1000 Silver Variant
- $18.73 2007 McFarlane Toys NFL Series 15 Indianapolis Colts Peyton Manning Figure
- $44.99 MCFARLANE NFL COLTS HOF QB PEYTON MANNING 12" INCH LOOSE VARIANT FIGURE
- $9.99 LOADED 2000 NFL Football Bulk Starting Lineup Auctions SLU WARNER OTTO CULPEPPER
- $74.99 Tom Brady Peyton Manning 3 inch mcfarlane and cards
- $109.99 McFarlane NFL Figure 3 Pack Tom Brady Peyton Manning Ben Roethlisberger NIB
- $50.00 McFarlane NFL Figure Series 34 PEYTON MANNING 6" Football RARE Chase Variant
- $40.00 PEYTON MANNING ( 6" ) ( 2009 ) McFARLANE TENNESSEE VOLUNTEERS COLLEGE FIGURE NIB
- $39.99 Assorted 12 Inch Boxed McFarlane Sportspicks NFL Brady MLB Ripken NHL NBA LeBron
- $18.99 McFarlane NFL Small Mini Pros Tom Brady Mini Figure New England Patriots
- $20.00 McFarlane Toys - NFL Small PROS Series 1 - Peyton Manning Orange Jersey 2013
- $19.99 GRACELYN RE-PLAYS NFL PACKERS HOF QB BRETT FAVRE POSABLE 4" FIGURE NEW SEALED
- $22.00 McFarlane Collector Toys 2010 NFL Series 24 #18 Peyton Manning 5 Colts Figure
- $16.99 Peyton Manning #18 Denver Broncos NFL Small Pros Series 1 Figure
- $30.00 PRO-BOTS COLTS 18 PEYTON MANNING Robot Action Figure 2008 NFL ToyQuest
- $19.95 Indianapolis Colts Peyton Manning NFL McFarlane Action Figure - With Stand
- $45.00 Custom Indianapolis Colts SBXL1 Peyton Manning Starting Line Up Figure
- $28.00 1998 BOB LILLY Dallas Cowboys Rookie #74 *FREE_s/h* sole Starting Lineup
- $12.00 MCFARLANE NFL SERIES 8 COLTS HOF QB PEYTON MANNING LOOSE COMPLETE FIGURE
- $19.99 PEYTON MANNING #2 - Indianapolis Colts - McFarlane NFL Series 8 - LOOSE - 2004
- $39.99 2012-2015 Custom McFarlane - Peyton Manning (#18) Denver Broncos Quarterback
- $28.88 McFarlane NFL DeSean Jackson Philadelphia Eagles Series 24 Action Figure SEALED!
- $42.95 McFarlane NFL Football Series 34 Broncos Peyton Manning Figure CHASE 444/1500
- $15.00 2006 Gracelyn Toys Re-Plays Series III Colts 18 Peyton Manning NFL #11035 T-20
- $24.99 2002 Peyton Manning Series 4 Mcfarlane Indianapolis Colts - Labelling Error
- $12.00 Peyton Manning Indianapolis Chase Variant Action Figure 2004 McFarlane NIP
- $50.00 Ronnie Lott NFL Legends Series 2 McFarlane Toys San Francisco 49ers
- $19.99 Assorted Packaged NFL Football McFarlane Sportspicks Brady Cowboys Packers HOF
- $35.00 MCFARLANE NFL 32 BRONCOS PEYTON MANNING CL VARIANT FIGURE /2500 SEALED COLTS
- $27.99 McFarlane NFL Sports Picks Series 16: Champ Bailey Action Figure Denver Broncos
- $169.00 McFarlane Toys NFL Figure Lot SportsPicks Newton Football 7” Madden LT Manning
- $24.99 MCFARLANE NFL INDIANAPOLIS COLTS PEYTON MANNING JIM HARBAUGH ACTION FIGURES NEW!
- $12.19 1999 Hasbro NFL Indianapolis Colts Starting Lineup Peyton Manning Figure
- $14.99 McFarlane Toys Figure - NFL smALL PROS Series 3 - Raiders Sebastian Janikowski
- $23.99 McFarlane Peyton Manning Figure Indianapolis Colts NFL Series 21 SEALED
- $14.99 Peyton Manning Series 4 Action Figure Indianapolis Colts McFarlane NFL 2002
- $22.99 Peyton Manning Eli Manning McFarlane Football Double Figure Box Colts Giants
- $10.00 2009 McFarlane Sportspicks 3 inch Series Action Figure Peyton Manning - Colts
- $33.14 McFarlane RONNIE LOTT SF 49ers Sports Picks Figure 2006 Legends Series 2 Sealed
- $24.88 McFarlane College Football Peyton Manning Tennessee Volunteers Action Figure
- $69.50 NFL Elite Quarterbacks 3-Pack TOM BRADY BEN ROTHLISBERGER PEYTON MANNING MIMB
- $34.99 NFL Series 32 Peyton Manning McFarlane Variant Big Head Chase Bronze Ltd /2500
- $22.99 LOOSE NFL RE-PLAYS: BIG BEN, URLACHER, PORTIS, STRAHAN, FAVRE, MARTIN, BRADY++
- $20.00 2010 McFarlane Sportspicks NFL Series 24 Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts
- $15.00 McFarlane Toys 2007 NFL Series 15 Indianapolis Colts Peyton Manning Figure
- $15.00 2000 extended ISAAC BRUCE St Saint Louis Rams #80 *FREE_s/h* Starting Lineup LA
- $2.95 KJ: 1998 Topps NFL Action Flats Peyton Manning Figure + CARD Indianapolis Colts
- $19.99 McFarlane Toys Football NFL Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Series 4 READ
- $7.99 Assorted Packaged NFL Football Starting Lineup SLU Packers Cowboys Patriots Jets
- $22.00 2005 Gladiators of the Gridiron Peyton Manning #18 Indianapolis Colts NIP
- $37.00 THE MANNING BROTHERS (Peyton & Eli) McFarlane figure Deluxe 2-Pack Set NIB NICE
- $13.00 1999-2000 Football NFL Kenner Starting Lineup Peyton Manning Colts #18 HOF
- $24.99 2007 McFarlane Sportspick NFL Series 15 Indianapolis Colts Peyton Manning Figure
- $14.00 PEYTON MANNING 2002 McFarlane Sportspicks Series 4 BLUE jersey variant COLTS
- $19.99 McFarlane Collector Toys 2010 NFL Series 24 #18 Peyton Manning 5 Colts Figure
- $12.50 2000-2001 PEYTON MANNING Starting Lineup Figure (Indianapolis Colts) NEW (White)
- $1.95 KJ: 1998 Topps NFL Action Flats Peyton Manning Figure + CARD Colts Missing Flap
- $12.99 Peyton Manning 2000 2001 Starting Lineup Figure White Jersey New Sealed SLU
- $22.49 McFarlane Peyton Manning Figure NFL Colts Player Toys R Us Exclusive Player
- $40.00 NFL Peyton Manning 4-inch action figure Playmakers 2011 moc
- $78.00 Mcfarlane 3 Pak Archie, Peyton, & Eli Manning 2009
- $74.00 McFarlane Sportspicks NFL Action Figure Lot Manning Manziel Leinart Winston 7”
- $21.95 2014 McFarlane NFL 34 Denver Broncos Peyton Manning #18
- $7.00 2000 ELITE Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Starting Lineup w/ Pacific card #18
- $8.50 2006 Gracelyn Toys Re-Plays Series III Brett Favre Throwback Figure Packers
- $10.00 NFL Football McFarlane Sportspicks Action Figures NFL Players - You Pick
- $49.99 McFarlane NFL Playmakers ADRIAN PETERSON Vikings White New Sealed NIB 2011
- $14.99 Peyton Manning Archie Manning 1999 2000 Classic Doubles Starting Lineup
- $49.95 2010 McFarlane Toys NFL Playmakers Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts 4” Figure
- $19.99 PEYTON MANNING INDIANAPOLIS COLTS MCFARLANE TARGET EXCLUSIVE RETRO 1955 UNIFORM!
- $21.99 2002 McFarlane Sportspicks | NFL Indianapolis Colts | Peyton Manning | Figure
- $10.00 1998 - 2001 NFL Football Starting Lineup Assorted Figures
- $17.00 Peyton Manning 2002 Mcfarlane NFL Indianapolis Colts Series 4 Blue Jersey
- $57.95 2011 McFarlane Series 2 Playmakers Drew Brees N.O. Saints 4-Inch Figure REDUCED!
- $249.95 MCFARLANE NFL ELITE QB BRADY ROETHLISBERGER MANNING 3 PACK FIGURE NIB
- $24.99 MCFARLANE TOYS NFL SERIES 25 PEYTON MANNING COLT CLASSIC '55 WHITE UNIFORM