Advent Calendars
Candle Holders
Candles
Cards & Postcards
Christmas Trees
Costumes
Figurines
Incense Smokers
Lanterns
Lights
Masks
Nativity Items
Noisemakers
Nutcrackers
Ornaments
Other Holiday Collectibles
Props
Pyramids
Snow Globes
Stockings & Hangers
Table Décor & Serving Pieces
Tree Stands & Skirts
Tree Toppers
Villages & Houses
Wall Décor
Window Decorations
Wreaths, Garlands & Plants
Yard Décor
- $45.00 Kurt Adler Polanaise Babe Ruth Glass Christmas Ornament 1998 Komozja AP914
- $25.00 Hallmark Ornament Santa at the Bat Dated 1987 in Box
- $19.99 Rare Vtg HTF Flocked Christmas Ornament Santa with Baseball Glove Hong Kong
- $12.99 Vintage 1994 Jeanne Beaury Santa Claus Christmas Figurine Baseball Pencil
- $11.99 Kurt S. Adler Santa Claus Baseball Player Christmas Ornament. Missing Bat! Nice!
- $9.99 Lot of 3 Vintage Baseball Batting Santa 3.5" Christmas Ornaments 1990's
- $24.99 Danbury Mint Ornament Boston Red Sox Christmas 2008 Santa Claus Lot Of 3
- $25.99 FOREVER COLLECTIBLES LICENSED MLB SET OF 2 BOSTON RED SOX ORNAMENTS
- $10.80 Hallmark Keepsake Christmas Ornament 1989 HERE'S THE PITCH Baseball Santa H9
- $7.97 Kurt Adler Santa Baseball Christmas Ornament Blown Glass
- $6.99 Hallmark Keepsake Ornament Perfect Catch 1990 Baseball Santa
- $8.00 Santa Claus on a Baseball with a Bat Christmas Ornament
- $6.99 Hallmark Keepsake Christmas Ornament 1989 HERE'S THE PITCH Baseball Santa
- $8.50 Hallmark Keepsake Ornament HERE’S THE PITCH vintage ornament 1989 Santa,Baseball
- $24.00 Hallmark Keepsake Ornament Baseball Santa Tennessee Volunteers 2001
- $14.44 Santa Claus Christmas Ornament Playing Baseball Pitcher Oakland A's Team 4.25"
- $11.16 Silvestri Santa Football/Baseball Player Ceramic Christmas Ornaments 2 VINTAGE
- $7.00 Vintage Hallmark Keepsake Ornament 1989 Here's The Pitch NOS New
- $34.99 Hallmark 2023 Spinning Heat Miser Year Without Santa Claus Keepsake Ornament
- $12.95 Santa Clause Ornament with Baseball Bat and Baseball
- $99.95 F Christopher Radko Baseball Santa Claus Ornament
- $6.99 Santa Claus Baseball Christmas Ornament
- $7.95 Vintage Baseball Bat Santa Claus Folk Art Hand Carved Painted Christmas Ornament
- $10.57 Kurt Adler Santa Claus baseball bat ornament Xmas
- $6.99 Santa Claus Playing Baseball With Elves Christmas Ornament
- $14.00 Santa Claus St Patrick Christmas Holiday Ornament 4" Tall Resin
- $10.00 CERAMIC SANTA CLAUS WITH BASEBALL BAT 2 IN CHRISTMAS ORNAMENT
- $6.99 Mini Santa Swinging Baseball Bat Christmas Tree Ornament 4.25"
- $19.95 Santa Claus Ornament , St Patrick Santa Presents 4" Tall Resin
- $19.95 Santa Claus Ornament , Golfin Santa Presents 4" Tall Resin
- $19.95 Santa Claus Ornament , Summertime Santa Presents 4" Tall Resin
- $19.95 Santa Claus Ornament , Springtime Santa Presents 4" Tall Resin
- $8.90 Silvestri Christmas Ornament Vintage Ceramic Santa Baseball
- $14.99 Pull String Santa Claus Baseball Christmas Ornament Wood GUC
- $9.99 Lot of 5 Vintage 3 Baseballs on strand 4" Christmas Ornaments 1990's
- $6.99 Santa Claus Baseball Body Christmas Ornament
- $39.95 13 Hallmark Keepsake 1980s Christmas Ornaments Mixed Lot Santa Angel ~NIB~ T294B
- $6.99 Santa Claus Baseball Body Blue Helmet Christmas Ornament
- $18.39 Russ New York Yankees Christmas Ornament Santa Beach Chair Collectible 5860 MLB
- $19.95 Santa Claus Ornament , St Nick Santa Presents 4" Tall Resin
- $5.24 Vintage SANTA CLAUS BASEBALL BAT Christmas Ornament Ganz
- $12.00 Vintage Baseball Player Santa Claus Ceramic Christmas Tree Ornament
- $6.99 Santa Claus Holding Baseball Glove and Baseball Christmas Ornament
- $6.99 Santa Claus Baseball Pitching Clay Christmas Ornament
- $3.99 CHRISTMAS TREE ORNAMENT BASEBALL SANTA CLAUS SPORTS ATHLETICS RESIN 3.5"
- $15.95 Vintage Christmas Baseball Santa Ornament Felt Covered Plastic 3”
- $14.99 Hallmark Keepsake Christmas Ornament 1989 HERE'S THE PITCH Baseball Santa
- $13.99 VTG Resin Santa Claus Playing Baseball Catching Baseball Christmas Ornament Y2K
- $9.00 VTG SANTA CLAUS BASEBALL 18” Christmas Stocking Felt Brushcreek Creative 1980s
- $11.87 Wooden Christmas Ornaments Mrs Santa Claus & Baseball Teddy Bear Vintage 1970s
- $29.99 Glass Large Baseball Santa Xmas Ornament 8” H
- $4.99 HOUSE OF LLOYD SANTA CLAUS PLAYING BASEBALL CHRISTMAS ORNAMENT HARD PLASTIC
- $9.00 Hallmark 1990 Keepsake Ornament Perfect Catch Baseball Santa Claus
- $4.99 THE BIGGEST Sports FAN Hallmark Keepsake ORNAMENT 2002 - NEW IN BOX
- $14.99 Vintage Silvestri Santa Claus Christmas tree ornament USED - MCM
- $7.99 TRIM A HOME Baseball Player Santa Claus Uniform #25 Wreath Christmas Ornament
- $14.99 Lot Of 4 Misc Hallmark Christmas Ornaments Baseball Volleyball Pinata And Bird
- $8.90 Hallmark Keepsake Ornament Santa At the Bat 1987 Baseball Softball Vintage
- $8.97 Vintage Hallmark Keepsake Ornament SANTA AT THE BAT 1987 Baseball Vintage
- $14.99 VINTAGE ORNAMENT "TIS THE SEASON" CHICAGO CUBS SANTA CLAUS BY RUSS OFFICIAL MLB
- $14.95 Mistletoe Magic Lustre Fame Matrix Tree Santa Claus Baseball Ornament
- $7.03 Brown & Blue Plush Milwaukee Baseball w Santa Claus Hat Christmas Tree Ornament
- $8.88 Hallmark Keepsake Ornament Fish Catch of the Season Fisherman 1998~~NICE!!!!
- $3.99 Mistletoe Magic Santa Claus in Baseball Uniform Christmas Ornament
- $12.00 Park City Santa Playing Football Christmas Tree Ornament Long Hat 7.5" Rare
- $9.99 2002 Hallmark Keepsake Ornament The Biggest Fan Santa Sports Fan
- $9.99 Vintage Santa Swinging Baseball Bat Christmas Ornament 5" Bisque Taiwan
- $19.95 Lot Of 6 Baseball Playing Santa Claus Christmas Tree Ornaments
- $6.70 CHRISTMAS ORNAMENTS BASEBALL SANTA CLAUS UNIFORM CLEATS SHOES SET Of 3
- $8.99 Hallmark Christmas Ornament Santa At The Bat Vintage 1987
- $9.99 Vintage Hand Carved Painted Baseball Bat Santa Claus Folk Art Christmas Ornament
- $9.00 Baseball Santa Claus Christmas Ornament with Baseball Glove and Baseball Bat
- $14.99 Oakland A's Sunbathing Santa MLB Baseball Ornament Santa Chillaxin Lawn Chair
- $11.99 Vintage Christmas Painted FOLK ART Egg Ornament Baseball Santa Cooperstown NY
- $9.99 Lot of 3 Vintage Baseball Batting Santa 5" Christmas Ornaments 1990's
- $5.00 Salt Shaker Santa, Ceramic, 4" tall,
- $12.00 Santa Claus Baseball Christmas Ornament North Pole Nicks
- $16.00 4 Ornament Lot Hallmark Keepsake Sports Santa Claus Bear Cupid Donder Baseball
- $30.80 Vintage Silvestri Santa Claus Christmas tree ornaments, set of 2. USED - MCM
- $8.99 Hallmark KEEPSAKE ORNAMENT "The Biggest Fan" (2002) with Original Box
- $28.00 HALLMARK KEEPSAKE ORNAMENT LOT REINDEER BASEBALL SANTA CLAUS NIGHT BEFORE XMAS
- $29.99 Christmas Ornament San Diego Padres Baseball Santa Claus 10" Plush Tree Vintage
- $5.99 Vintage Hallmark Keepsake Ornament 1989 Here's The Pitch QX545-5
- $10.00 Vintage 1987 Hallmark Keepsake Ornament "Santa At The Bat" North Pole Nicks
- $5.99 5 1/2” Baseball Bat Santa Claus Christmas Ornament
- $29.99 Pickleball Mrs Claus Ornament
- $8.95 Forever Collectibles Santa In Boston Red Sox Uniform Team Ornament
- $18.98 Park City Baseball Santa Claus Christmas Tree Ornament 7.5 Inch Tall
- $12.99 Mistletoe Magic Matrix Tree Santa Claus in Baseball Uniform Lustre Fame Ornament
- $9.00 Vintage Flocked Felt Baseball Player Santa Christmas Ornament Brown Mit 3.5”
- $10.99 MLB St Louis Cardinals Santa Claus Blown Glass Christmas Tree Ornament
- $8.99 Baseball Santa Christmas Tree Ornament Ceramic
- $12.50 Set Of 2 Vintage Resin Santa Claus Baseball/Softball Christmas Ornaments
- $12.95 Vintage Christmas Baseball Bat Glove Santa Claus Tree Ornament Resin 3.75" Nice
- $9.74 Ceramic Baseball Player Ball Santa Claus Christmas Ornament
- $20.00 Clippers Santa Claus Christmas Tree Ornament Memory Company 2001 Official
- $15.00 Hallmark KEEPSAKE ORNAMENT "The Biggest Fan" (2002) with Original Box
- $10.00 THE BIGGEST Sports FAN Hallmark Keepsake ORNAMENT 2002 - NEW IN BOX
- $19.95 Santa Claus Ornament ,Baseball Santa Presents 4" Tall Resin
- $18.99 HALLMARK 1989 Here's The Pitch & NORTH POLE JOGGER & 1988 GONE FISHING LOT OF 3