NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission.
Learn more*
Best Match
Newest
Ending
Lowest Price
Highest Price
Best Match
Newest
Ending
Lowest Price
Highest Price
S
M
L
XL
Share
Share
Twitter
Facebook
Email
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Buffy The Vampire Slayer Men of Sunnydale Trading Card #48 James Marsters Spike
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Buffy The Vampire Slayer Men of Sunnydale Trading Card #54 James Marsters Spike
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Inkworks Spike The Complete Storie Trading Card #52 Bloody Pains Glory
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$1.50
CHEAP PROMO CARD: SPIKE THE COMPLETE STORY from Buffy Inkworks 2005 #P-UK
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$7.95
BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER THE MEN OF SUNNYDALE 2005 Complete Card Set
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Buffy The Vampire Slayer Season 5 TV Show Trading Card #42 James Marsters Spike
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Inkworks Spike The Complete Storie Trading Card #24 James Marsters Spike
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$2.50
CHEAP PROMO CARD: SPIKE THE COMPLETE STORY from Buffy Inkworks 2005 #P-UKP
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Buffy The Vampire Slayer Season 2 TV-Show Trading Card #17 James Marsters Spikes
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Buffy The Vampire Slayer Season 5 TV Show Trading Card #45 James Marsters Spike
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$3.99
InkWorks 2005 BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER MEN OF SUNNYDALE 81 card Base Set zm
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$64.88
2005 SPIKE THE COMPLETE STORY JAMES MARSTERS AS SPIKE PIECEWORKS CARD PW1 + PR1
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Buffy The Vampire Slayer Season 5 TV Show Trading Card #39 James Marsters Spike
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Buffy The Vampire Slayer Men of Sunnydale Trading Card #49 James Marsters Spike
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$1.50
BUFFY - PROMO CARD 2003 BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER SEASON 7 Inkworks #B7-4 SPIKE
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Buffy The Vampire Slayer Men of Sunnydale Trading Card #52 James Marsters Spike
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$2.99
Angel Season 5 TV Show A5-1 Promo Trading Card David Boreanaz James Marsters
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$24.99
Angel Season 5 PW6 Spike Shirt James Marsters Pieceworks Card Inkworks Buffy
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$49.99
2023 Leaf Pop Century #ed /10 James Marsters AUTO, Pink , BUFFY, ANGEL
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Inkworks Spike The Complete Storie Trading Card #47 Bloody Pains Angel
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Inkworks Spike The Complete Storie Trading Card #49 Bloody Pains Riley
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Inkworks Spike The Complete Storie Trading Card #67 Buffy Bot
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Inkworks Spike The Complete Storie Trading Card #64 Drusilla
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Inkworks Spike The Complete Storie Trading Card #50 Bloody Pains Giles
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$129.57
2003 Buffy The Vampire Slayer Connections #19 Spike + Drusilla PSA 10 POP 1
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Buffy The Vampire Slayer Men of Sunnydale Trading Card #53 James Marsters Spike
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$13.49
Lot of 36 - 2002 - 2007 Inkworks Buffy the Vampire Slayer Sarah Michelle Gellar
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Inkworks Spike The Complete Storie Trading Card #53 Bloody Pains Pavayne
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Inkworks Spike The Complete Storie Trading Card #16 James Marsters Spike
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$15.00
BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER SEASON 6 Complete BUFFY BOYZ Box Loader Card Set (3)
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Inkworks Spike The Complete Storie Trading Card #72 Checklist
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$10.99
BUFFY Vampire Slayer SPIKE James Marsters BTVS SKETCH Card PRINT open edition
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Inkworks Spike The Complete Storie Trading Card #71 Fred
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$124.99
Buffy Spike The Complete Story A1 James Marsters Autograph Card Inkworks
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Buffy Reflections Trading Card #57 James Marsters as Spike
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$3.50
CHEAP PROMO CARD: SPIKE THE COMPLETE STORY from Buffy Inkworks 2005 #P-i
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Inkworks Spike The Complete Storie Trading Card #46 Bloody Pains The Master
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$16.00
SPIKE (from BUFFY) (Inkworks/2005) "BLOODLINES" CASE LOADER CARD #CL1
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Buffy Season 5 TV-Show Trading Card #81 James Marsters as Spike
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Buffy Season 5 TV-Show Trading Card #55 James Marsters as Spike
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Inkworks Spike The Complete Storie Trading Card #33 James Marsters Spike
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Inkworks Spike The Complete Storie Trading Card #40 James Marsters Spike
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Buffy Men of Sunnydale TV Show Trading Card #46 James Marsters Spike
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Buffy Big Bads Trading Card #44 James Marsters as Spike
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Inkworks Spike The Complete Storie Trading Card #51 Bloody Pains Robin Wood
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Buffy The Vampire Slayer Season 3 TV-Show Trading Card #24 Spike
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Inkworks Spike The Complete Storie Trading Card #65 Harmony
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Inkworks Spike The Complete Storie Trading Card #69 Buffy
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Inkworks Spike The Complete Storie Trading Card #70 Anya
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$5.99
Inkworks 6 Promo Card Lot: 4 Buffy the Vampire Slayer Cards, Angel, Spike
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Inkworks Spike The Complete Storie Trading Card #10 James Marsters Spike
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Buffy The Vampire Slayer Men of Sunnydale Trading Card #47 James Marsters Spike
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Inkworks Spike The Complete Storie Trading Card #48 Bloody Pains Xander
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$29.99
BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER ULTIMATE COLLECTOR'S SET 3 20TH METAL RETRO MR8 SPIKE
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Inkworks Spike The Complete Storie Trading Card #68 Dawn
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$1000.00
2017 Buffy The Vampire Slayer Ultimate Collector's Set 3 MASTER Set Of 14 Cards!
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Buffy Men of Sunnydale TV Show Trading Card #51 James Marsters as Spike
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$1.25
Buffy the Vampire Slayer: Season 5 SINGLE Non-Sport Trading Card Inkworks 2001
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Buffy The Vampire Slayer Men of Sunnydale Trading Card #50 James Marsters Spike
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$1.87
Spike The Complete Story Spike And Buffy Chase Card SB6
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.99
Buffy The Vampire Slayer Season 3 TV-Show Trading Card #22 Spike
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$4.00
Buffy the Vampire Slayer CCG Angel's Curse #97 Spike Rare
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$1.25
Buffy the Vampire Slayer: Reflections SINGLE Non-Sport Trading Card by Inkworks
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$11.90
Johnny Lightning Buffy the Vampire Slayer Quote Card Spike - I love to brag
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$1.25
Buffy the Vampire Slayer: Evolution SINGLE Non-Sport Trading Card by Inkworks
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$1.25
Buffy the Vampire Slayer: Season 3 SINGLE Non-Sport Trading Card Inkworks 1999
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$1.25
Buffy the Vampire Slayer: Memories SINGLE Non-Sport Trading Card by Inkworks '06
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$11.90
Johnny Lightning Buffy the Vampire Slayer Quote Card Spike - I'm a bad rude man
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$1.25
Buffy the Vampire Slayer: 10th Anniversary SINGLE Non-Sport Trading Card 2007
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$11.90
Johnny Lightning Buffy the Vampire Slayer Quote Card Spike - She's the gnat
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$1.25
Buffy the Vampire Slayer: Connections SINGLE Non-Sport Trading Card by Inkworks
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$23.50
BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER SEASON 1 (1998) Complete Card Set with bonus set
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$1.25
Spike: The Complete Story SINGLE Non-Sport Trading card by Inkworks 2005
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$7.93
Buffy the Vampire Slayer Fan Club SDCC 2000 Exclusive Promo Spike #2 Inkworks
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$39.00
SPIKE Inkworks 2005 JAMES MARSTERS Art Card #BV1 BORIS VALLEJO Signed Autograph
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$9.99
SPIKE: THE COMPLETE STORY (2005) Complete Card Set JAMES MARSTERS Buffy, Angel
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$1.25
Buffy the Vampire Slayer: Season 7 SINGLE Non-Sport Trading Card Inkworks 2003
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$14.46
BTVS BUFFY SPIKE JAMES MARSTERS IK 2005 COMPLETE 72 CARD BASE SET + PACK WRAP
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$16.00
James Marsters as SPIKE SketchCard SKETCH CARD Chris Henderson 2 of 5
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$1.25
Buffy the Vampire Slayer: Season 4 SINGLE Non-Sport Trading Card Inkworks 2000
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$10.05
85 CARDS BASE SET Incomplet BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER WOMEN OF SUNNYDALE TRADING
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$1.25
Buffy the Vampire Slayer: Season 6 SINGLE Non-Sport Trading Card Inkworks 2002
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$299.99
2000 Inkworks Angel SPIKE JAMES MARSTERS SIGNED A5 Autograph Card AA
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$1.25
Buffy the Vampire Slayer: Season 2 SINGLE Non-Sport Trading Card Inkworks 1999
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$16.00
James Marsters as SPIKE SketchCard SKETCH CARD Chris Henderson 1 of 5
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$6.99
2005 INKWORKS SPIKE THE COMPLETE STORY HEROES JOURNEY Box topper set BL1-BL3
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$3.76
Inkworks Spike The Complete Story Heart & Soul Trading Card HS-9
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$399.99
Signed Contract JAMES MARSTERS Inkworks AUTOGRAPH Card Certification SPIKE Buffy
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$3.76
Inkworks Spike The Complete Story Heart & Soul Trading Card HS-4
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$3.76
Inkworks Spike The Complete Story Heart & Soul Trading Card HS-8
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$10.23
Promo Card - Buffy the Vampire Slayer Big Bads #Pi Internet Exclusive Spike ZPR2
MORE