Advent Calendars
Candle Holders
Candles
Cards & Postcards
Christmas Trees
Costumes
Figurines
Incense Smokers
Lanterns
Lights
Masks
Nativity Items
Noisemakers
Nutcrackers
Ornaments
Other Holiday Collectibles
Props
Pyramids
Snow Globes
Stockings & Hangers
Table Décor & Serving Pieces
Tree Stands & Skirts
Tree Toppers
Villages & Houses
Wall Décor
Window Decorations
Wreaths, Garlands & Plants
Yard Décor
- $48.88 Vintage December Diamonds Angelica the Angel Fish Christmas Ornament Blue
- $19.95 December Diamonds 79-81489 Resin Fairy on a Leaf Christmas Ornament 3.75"
- $40.00 Vtg December Diamonds Rainbow Manatee Float Ornament Tiki Drink Florida Pride
- $22.57 december diamonds Octopus Ornament New Purple Fat Lady Funny Kitchy Hanging Cute
- $34.99 December Diamonds "Nurse Six Pack" Merman Ornament 2020 FREE SHIPPING
- $36.99 December Diamonds "gay-mer 2" 2019 Christmas Mermaid Ornament Ships Free
- $19.95 December Diamonds 79-81487 Resin Fantasy Gold Glitter Elf Christmas Ornament 4"
- $36.99 December Diamonds Cajun Merman Ornament 2010 NEW with Box Tags
- $39.99 December Diamonds Clint, the Cowboy Merman Christmas Ornament 55-90202
- $36.99 December Diamonds "Beached Whale ornament 2020 Free Shipping
- $35.00 December Diamonds MUSCLE BEACH II Merman Ornament 2022 Collector's Box Brand New
- $149.99 Rare 2009 December Diamonds Salty Sailor Navy Merman Holiday Christmas Ornament
- $32.00 December Diamonds, Mermens 2022, Sk8r Boy
- $35.00 December Diamonds Soda It's All About the Bling! Mermaid Christmas Ornament 2012
- $39.99 December Diamonds Fish Bait Ornament
- $49.16 December Diamonds Seahorse Blown Glass Seahorse with Sparkles Lot Of 3!
- $36.99 December Diamonds "Miss Fishionista" Breakfast at Tiffanys Mermaid RETIRED
- $39.99 December Diamonds 55-55337 Poke The Bear Series Ornament, Sailor Bear
- $19.95 December Diamonds 9" Ball On Sphere Christmas Ornament White 08-08546
- $36.99 December Diamonds, Mermens 2024, AXIS.
- $22.95 December Diamonds 79-81237 Silver Glitter Glass Peacock 5"x4" Ornament
- $14.99 December Diamonds Cocker Spaniel Diva Ornament
- $45.00 December Diamonds SEBASTIAN the Caribbean Pirate Merman Ornament 2014, Gift Box
- $36.00 December Diamonds I'm a Fairy Valor Christmas Tree Ornament Multicolor
- $36.99 December Diamonds Grecian God Merman Christmas Tree Ornament Multicolor
- $49.95 December Diamonds RENEGADE Warlock Witch Merman Ornament 2023 Brand New in Box
- $36.99 December Diamonds 55-55333 Resin Poke The Bear Series, Rugby Bear
- $39.99 December Diamonds Cosmo Merman ornament 2004 Retired Original Box
- $36.99 December Diamonds, Mermens 2024, TRUCKER
- $19.00 Retired December Diamonds She Gull The Sea Gull Ornament. Diamonds Of The Sea
- $17.99 MISS FRAN PURPLE OCTOPUS DECEMBER DIAMONDS TREE ORNAMENT
- $254.99 December Diamonds Lucky Charm Merman Ornament Irish Green St Patricks Day 2014
- $20.99 December Diamonds 79-81284 Blown Glass Pastel Seahorse Ornament
- $19.95 December Diamonds 79-81498 Glass Resin Ornament Resin Fairy Queen Ornament 4.75"
- $41.95 NEW ! December Diamonds FATHER PRIDE Merman Ornament 2024 - IN STOCK
- $16.95 December Diamonds 79-81606 Ocean Breeze Turtle 5" Glass Christmas Ornament
- $24.49 December Diamonds "Agnes The Alligator" Christmas Ornament RETIRED Free Shipping
- $64.00 RARE December Diamonds TOOL Handyman Merman Ornament-2013 New in Box,-RETIRED
- $16.79 Witch Ornament Hell On Wheels By December Diamond 7x5 Green Orange Glitter
- $36.99 December Diamonds "GAYBRIEL" Heavenly Angel Merman Ornament 2021 - FREE SHIPPING
- $50.00 December Diamonds Atlantis Pirate Merman Ornament 2004 With Box Retired
- $49.95 2008 December Diamonds Johnson Merman Ornament Military Man Dog Tags Rare
- $34.99 December Diamonds WHO'S YOUR DADDY Bear Merman Ornament 2018, Brand New in Box
- $24.95 December Diamonds 79-80732 Dog Poodle w/ Dress 4.5" Glass Christmas Ornament
- $14.99 December Diamonds MAGNET Jack O Lantern Gay Halloween Merman
- $36.99 December Diamonds OUTBACK Merman Ornament -New in the Box!
- $8.99 December Diamonds MAGNET Rhinestone Cowgirl Cowboy Mermaid Decorative Novelty
- $13.59 December Diamond Christmas ornament peacock dangle 79-80456 9” purple blue green
- $50.39 December Diamonds Big Package Merman Christmas Ornament 5555105 New
- $32.95 New Set of 3 Gingerbread Cookie Christmas Ornaments Mrs Claus Bakery Snowflake
- $34.99 December Diamonds Cuddles Ornament
- $37.99 December Diamonds ROSEBUD Merman Ornament 2023 Brand New IN STOCK
- $71.96 14" December Diamonds Coastal Santa Figure Doll Beach Ocean Christmas Decor
- $15.99 December Diamonds large butterfly Christmas ornament 7” x 8 1/4” clipon green
- $36.99 December Diamonds Poke the Bear Rubber Bear Christmas Ornament Multicolor
- $23.95 December Diamonds 79-81666 Mr. Tiger w/ Gifts Glass Christmas Ornament
- $29.95 December Diamonds Tiered Gingerbread Cake In Cloche 4.5" Christmas Ornament
- $19.95 December Diamonds 79-81496 Resin Fairy Hedgehog Ornament 4" Christmas
- $36.99 December Diamonds I'm a Fairy Valor Christmas Tree Ornament Multicolor
- $39.99 IN STOCK December Diamonds BIG TUBE merman NEW 2024 mermen mermaid buoy Float
- $39.95 NEW ! December Diamonds AXIS Global Unity Merman Ornament 2024 - IN STOCK
- $8.99 December Diamonds MAGNET Cherry Blossom African American Mermaid
- $36.99 December Diamonds I'm a Fairy Zach Christmas Tree Ornament Multicolor
- $24.99 December Diamonds Ornament Miss Ruby with Red Hat Very Gently Used
- $36.99 December Diamonds "Pup" Puppy Play Ornament merman Free Shipping
- $15.99 December Diamonds ornament shoe embellished rhinestones 79-00083A green
- $25.00 Anthromorphic Fish Christmas ornament Red Hat Pearls Glitter December Diamonds
- $19.95 December Diamonds Green Tail Mermaid w/ Pearl 4" Christmas Ornament
- $15.99 December Diamonds glass 79-00085 glitter purple blue red ornament teardrop
- $19.95 December Diamonds Mermaid Sitting on Seashell 8" Glass Christmas Ornament
- $16.95 December Diamonds 79-81300 Seafoam Coral Teardrop 6" Christmas Ornament
- $17.59 December Diamonds ornament peacock pd angle feather rhinestones 79-000294
- $21.95 December Diamonds 79-81517 Resin Santa in a Flamingo Float 4" Christmas Ornament
- $24.99 December Diamonds - LUNA Angel of the Moon and Stars - angle ornament --
- $14.40 December Diamonds Green Beaded LOLLIPOP Blown Glass Christmas Ornament New NWT
- $23.95 December Diamonds 79-81490 Resin Fairy On Hummingbird Ornament 4 Inches
- $23.95 December Diamonds North Pole Sweet Shoppe Gingerbread Santa Ornament
- $23.95 December Diamonds 79-81350 Glass & Resin Rainbow Unicorn 4.5" Ornament
- $19.19 December Diamond glass Christmas 79-79475 6 1/2” x 2” alligator gator ornament
- $8.99 December Diamonds MAGNET Nurse Feel Better Mermaid
- $45.00 December Diamonds Mistletoe Santa 2020 Merman In Glass Ornament
- $32.95 December Diamonds 05-05097 Set Of 2 Assortment 4" Mr & Mrs Santa Fish Ornaments
- $39.95 NEW ! December Diamonds KEY LIME DADDY Merman Ornament 2024 - IN STOCK
- $19.95 December Diamonds 79-81736 Bulldog w/ Gingerbread Costume Glass Ornament
- $19.95 December Diamonds 79-81297 Pastel Plump Santa Swimming 5" Christmas Ornament
- $30.00 December Diamonds "Matilda" Which Witch? Halloween Ornament Free Shipping
- $44.99 December Diamonds Miss Ruby Ornament Glittery Red Lips Red Hat Painted Nails
- $21.95 December Diamonds 05-05134 Irish Santa Claus w/ Bag Hanging Christmas Ornament
- $41.95 NEW ! December Diamonds HYDROS Dolphin Merman Ornament 2024 - IN STOCK
- $13.59 December Diamonds Pearl seahorse 79-00045C 7” x 3” ornament encrusted
- $24.95 December Diamonds Glass Pink Flamingo w/ Drink 6" Ornament Christmas Holiday
- $14.95 December Diamonds 79-81742 Dog Bone w/ Red Bow 5" Christmas Ornament
- $18.39 December Diamond glass Christmas ornament adorable purple mermaid 79-79476
- $52.50 December Diamonds 2013 Red Hot Jingle Merman Holiday Ornament SHIPS FREE
- $55.99 Vintage December Diamonds Sammy The Sailor Merman Holiday Ornament China 2004
- $38.99 December Diamonds Big Easy Mardi Gras Merman Ornament 2023 Brand New in Box
- $49.99 Vintage December Diamonds Poseidon Pirate Merman Holiday Ornament China 2003
- $24.99 Pterodactyl Dinosaur with Wings 79-81104 Christmas Ornament
- $49.95 December Diamonds Sammy the Sailor Merman Mermaid Ornament 2001 LGBTQ Christmas
- $42.00 December Diamonds Bubbles Shopping Lady "Sale Fish" - Ornament Collectible