Advent Calendars
Candle Holders
Candles
Cards & Postcards
Christmas Trees
Costumes
Figurines
Incense Smokers
Lanterns
Lights
Masks
Nativity Items
Noisemakers
Nutcrackers
Ornaments
Other Holiday Collectibles
Props
Pyramids
Snow Globes
Stockings & Hangers
Table Décor & Serving Pieces
Tree Stands & Skirts
Tree Toppers
Villages & Houses
Wall Décor
Window Decorations
Wreaths, Garlands & Plants
Yard Décor
- $49.85 Vintage German Baby's First Christmas Pink Glass Ornaments Bear Pacifier Bootle
- $75.00 Rattle Ornament 1999 - Babys First Christmas Rattle - Porcelain
- $40.00 Vintage Baby First Ornaments 1998 Lot Of 11 Pieces Assorted 
- $189.99 Nativity Set 10 pc Hand Painted Porcelain Lighted Creche Christmas Season
- $10.50 Baby boy's first Christmas stocking elephant blue design polyester
- $6.00 Baby Girl First Christmas Stocking Pink Plush Used Beautiful Condition
- $11.99 Babys First Christmas Stocking 18" Pink and White Plush Teddy Bear Embroidered
- $13.49 Vtg Christmas Stocking Baby Knit Green Red Pom Pom Sock MCM Retro 20 inch
- $16.00 Baby's First Christmas 2023 Christmas ornament (v. nice)
- $13.50 Baby's First Christmas Tree Ornament Snowman with Snow Glass Blue White Boy
- $12.41 Pink Baby Girl Packages Stork w/Baby Girl Stork Christmas Ornament Lot of 2
- $6.00 Baby Boy First Christmas Stocking Blue Plush Used Beautiful Condition
- $6.99 Vintage Baby's First Christmas Beaded rocking horse Christmas ornament- NEW
- $17.99 Baby's First Christmas Knit Christmas Stocking White Red Pom Pom Holly Vintage
- $19.98 Baby's First Christmas Stocking Girl Pink & White Snowman Felt Material
- $19.98 Baby's First Christmas Stocking Girl Pink & White Plaid Felt Material
- $13.13 Baby Blue Shoes - Cute Gift Idea For Baby Shower Or Christmas Ornament 4''
- $16.00 Baby's First Christmas 2023 Christmas ornament (v. nice)
- $11.00 Vintage Christmas Stocking Baby’s First Knit Green Red 12” Sock MCM Retro
- $9.31 VTG Baby's First Christmas Felt Stocking 15" Kitten Holly Santa Snowman Gifts
- $24.95 Baby Girl Ornament, Sterling Silver Center w/Cherubs, Silvertone Metal Frame
- $18.00 Baby Bump's First Christmas ornament 2023: two sided (v. nice)
- $32.91 BABY'S 1ST CHRISTMAS GIRL ORNAMENT~BLOWN GLASS BABY SHOES~BOOTIES~PINK~NWT
- $16.00 Baby's First Christmas ornament (v. nice)
- $10.99 Baby's First Christmas Stocking Girl 2008 Dated Pink Stars
- $16.00 Baby's First Christmas ornament (v. nice)
- $12.99 Baby’s First Christmas Brown Bear Yellow Shirt in Crib Ornament
- $8.99 Baby’s First Christmas ROCKING HORSE Ornament-“GOD BLESS BABY’S FIRST..” Girl
- $15.98 Vintage baby's first Christmas cradle bottle ornament teddy bear Xmas decor
- $35.00 Vintage Mercury Glass Baby Shoe Bootie Ornament 1st Christmas West Germany Gold
- $24.99 Christmas: "Baby's 1st Christmas (2022)" Stockings (Set Of 2), NWT
- $48.95 Promoted to Grandpa Ornament est 2022, New Grandpa Gift, First Time Grandpa
- $4.50 Baby's First 2022 Bear Ornament Pink
- $10.50 Baby girl's first Christmas stocking elephant pink design polyester
- $129.00 Antique German Christmas Ornament Swaddled Baby Doll Paper Mache Germany Figure
- $14.99 Baby boy blue first holiday ornaments duck pacifier car shoe block bottle in box
- $5.96 Baby's First Christmas Door Hanging Pillow Plush Teddy Bear Snowflakes Blue 6x4
- $2.00 Baby Block Ornaments Shower Gift Toppers Lilac & Mint Green Plastic Raised Art
- $31.98 3 Christmas Stockings Velvet 18.5” Glitter Soft Colors 
- $14.99 VTG Frosted Glass Acrylic Noah's Ark Ornament 5" Clear Glittery ICY look
- $32.91 BABY'S 1ST CHRISTMAS BOY ORNAMENT~BLOWN GLASS BABY SHOES~BOOTIES~BLUE~NWT
- $4.95 Baby’s First Christmas Ornament ~ Teddy Bear on Rocking Horse 4”
- $32.91 BLOWN GLASS 2019 BABY'S FIRST~1ST CHRISTMAS RATTLE ORNAMENT~PINK~GIRL~NWT
- $22.00 Vtg Baby's First Christmas Ornaments Set Of 7 Boy Blue Bottle Train Block Bear
- $12.00 Vintage Baby's First Christmas 14 Inch Felt Christmas Stocking W/ Teddy Bear
- $12.00 Baby's First Christmas kitten quilted Felt Christmas Stocking
- $10.99 Baby's First Christmas Holiday Pink Plush Snowman Sparkle Stocking 16"
- $16.99 Knitted Christmas Stocking Baby's Christmas Stocking Blue Pink Long Poms Vintage
- $8.00 Baby’s first Christmas red and white 18in stocking
- $4.21 BABY GIRLS FIRST CHRISTMAS PINK STOCKING TEDDY BEAR 2021 SOFT PLUSH CUTE!
- $9.79 3 Baby's First Christmas Stocking Ornaments Blue Felt Teddy Bears lot of 3
- $14.95 7 Baby Ornaments In Box - Baby Bottle Pacifier Duck Shoe Bear 90's
- $10.00 Baby 's 1 st Christmas Stocking w/Teddy Bear, Gifts
- $13.56 The JWM Collection Baby's First Christmas Blue Boy Holiday Ornaments
- $25.55 Vintage 1988 Baby's First Christmas Sheep Ornament
- $9.99 Baby's Christmas Stocking Knitted Christmas Stocking Blue Pink Long Poms Vintage
- $8.88 Baby Girl First Christmas Stocking. Lt. Green/Pink. Approx. 14" EUC.
- $9.99 Pink Fleece “Babies 1st Christmas” Christmas Stockings Embroidery Set of 3
- $19.99 Sleeping Baby Angel Ornament Blue Plastic Vintage Boy Baby's First Christmas
- $10.95 Baby's First 16" Blue & Pink Knit Stocking Holiday
- $20.00 Baby’s First Christmas 4 Glass Ornaments 1st Vtg New Shower Gift Heart Bottle
- $6.00 Baby's First Christmas Stocking Hat Ornament blue NWT
- $17.99 Vtg Baby's First Christmas Ornaments Set Of 7 Boy Blue Bottle Train
- $14.99 Highland Cow Wood Baby's First Christmas Ornament
- $29.00 Vintage Baby's First Christmas Pink Glass Ornaments Germany Carriage Bear Shoe
- $9.99 Baby's First Christmas Ornament - 3” Blue To Be Personalized & Dated Stork Boxed
- $4.77 Vintage Infant in her Christening Gown Christmas Ornament - Rare -Nursery -Baby
- $10.23 A PAIR OF PORCELAIN BABY BOOTIES 1.25” X 2.25” HANGING ORNAMENT UNBRANDED
- $11.25 babys first christmas stocking sheep removable bear delicate embroidered
- $21.99 7 Baby Boy Blue Blown Glass Ornaments Bottle Bootie Block Pacifier Duck Bear Car
- $4.95 Vintage Christmas Tree ORNAMENT Wooden BEAR on ROCKING CHAIR Baby's First Xmas
- $9.99 Baby's First Christmas Ornament 3” Pink Girl To Be Personalized & Dated Stork
- $12.99 CHRISTMAS STOCKING PINK SOFT BABY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS 2010 NEW
- $15.00 Baby’s 1st Christmas Basket Tree Ornament Person Of Color Boy
- $34.99 Baby’s First 1st Christmas Satin Ball Ornament 1993
- $14.99 Baby's First 1st Christmas Puppy Stocking 2005 NOS w Tags Kmart Blue White
- $7.99 Baby's First Christmas Glass Heart Christmas ornament- Blue/Boy NEW
- $22.00 Charming Leather Baby Button Up Shoe Ornament!
- $14.99 1991 Unbranded Ornament My First Christmas Bear Rocking Horse baby 3 1/2"
- $8.00 Christmas Ornament Rocking Horse Teddy Bear Gifts White Gold.
- $20.00 Christmas Ball Ornament Hand Painted 2011 A Partidge A Pear Tree Holiday Decor
- $7.00 Baby's First Christmas Stocking Hat Ornament pink + pink camo mini stocking NWT
- $19.99 VINTAGE Set of 2 Sleeping & Praying Baby Angels Ornaments Plastic Pink and Blue
- $9.97 Teddy Bear Ornament White With Ear Muffs Brown With Horse Babys First Christmas
- $12.99 Hand-painted Santa Claus w/ Snow & Trees on Frosted Blown Glass Ornament 2003
- $19.99 set 2 Babys First Christmas Baby Arrival Joyous Angel playin horn carriage VTG
- $17.91 HONEY~TEDDY BEAR~BABY'S 1ST CHRISTMAS ORNAMENT~TERM OF ENDEARMENT~NWT
- $8.99 Baby's First Christmas Snowman With Hat In Stocking With Trees Blue And White
- $29.00 Charming Leather Baby Shoe Ornament!
- $5.99 Baby's First 1st Christmas Snowman Stocking Blues White Brown Fleece 13" Long
- $20.00 Vintage BABY'S 1st CHRISTMAS HandStitched Quilted Christmas Stocking Snowman ⛄️
- $14.98 Baby's First Christmas Photo Holder Christmas Ornament! PEWTER! NEW! GLITTER!
- $12.99 Baby's First Christmas Ornament Baby Girl First Christmas Ornament
- $9.75 Baby in Cradle 3.5" Xmas Ornament Bottom Reads "Baby's First" White -B12
- $12.00 Baby's First Christmas plush stocking, girl's dress on clothesline w clothespins
- $6.90 Vintage Baby's First Christmas Tree Ornaments Girl Rocking Horse Picture 4"
- $9.79 GIRL Baby's (First) Christmas Ornament OneZ with Castle Can Be Personalized
- $8.00 Cloth Heart Red Green Plaid Bear Balloon Baby’s First Christmas Ornament
- $12.99 Baby's First Christmas Ornament Pink Heart Sleeper Jumper Miniature Dollhouse
- $14.99 VTG Folk Art Wood Ornaments Hand Crafted Angels Lot of 3