Advent Calendars
Candle Holders
Candles
Cards & Postcards
Christmas Trees
Costumes
Figurines
Incense Smokers
Lanterns
Lights
Masks
Nativity Items
Noisemakers
Nutcrackers
Ornaments
Other Holiday Collectibles
Props
Pyramids
Snow Globes
Stockings & Hangers
Table Décor & Serving Pieces
Tree Stands & Skirts
Tree Toppers
Villages & Houses
Wall Décor
Window Decorations
Wreaths, Garlands & Plants
Yard Décor
- $21.25 2022 Hallmark BABY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS BUGGY Porcelain Ornament Lot C23
- $13.93 1993 Hallmark Silver Baby's First Christmas Rattle Ornament With Blank Tag & Bow
- $14.99 1993 Hallmark Silver Baby's First Christmas Rattle Ornament With Blank Tag & Bow
- $29.99 Wendell August Baby’s First Christmas Ornament Handmade Solid Bronze Moon Stars
- $7.99 Hallmark BABY BOY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS Blue Bear Booties Keepsake Ornament NEW
- $14.99 Precious Moments BABY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS Tree Ornament 1989 # 523194 NEW
- $8.99 Hallmark Keepsake - Baby Girl's First Christmas - 2019 **NEW / FREE SHIPPING**
- $17.95 Hallmark Baby's First Christmas ornament 2018 Porcelain Rattle Unisex
- $3.74 Hallmark BABY BOY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS Blue Bear Booties Keepsake Ornament NEW
- $19.95 Hallmark Baby's First Christmas 2023 Rattle Ornament Premium Metal Pink 1st
- $9.99 Hallmark Baby's First Christmas Photo Holder Keepsake Ornament REPAINT NO DATE
- $12.98 2022 Hallmark BABY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS BUGGY Stroller Porcelain Ornament Free ship
- $14.99 2004 Baby’s First Christmas African American Vintage Hallmark Ornament QXG5711
- $18.00 Vtg ENESCO & Handmade Christmas Ornament Lot Of Three FAST SHIPPING 🛳️💨
- $29.88 Hallmark Baby's First Christmas 2023 Rattle Ornament Premium Metal Pink 1st
- $10.50 Merck Family Old World Christmas Baby’s First Christmas Teddy Bear Ornament 2001
- $9.99 Kate & Milo My First Christmas Photo Ornament White Red Green New In Package
- $1.99 Christmas Tree Picture Frame Ornament-My First Christmas 2022 2x3inch
- $15.99 Hallmark Keepsake 1995 Baby's First Christmas Baby Bear Silver Cup Tag Ornament
- $13.95 Hallmark 2022 BABY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS BUGGY Stroller Porcelain Ornament 23-30
- $37.99 Hallmark Little Sweet Pea Baby’s First Christmas Ornament SPECIAL EDITION 2009
- $12.99 Christmas Tree Picture Frame Ornament-My First Christmas 2x3inch
- $37.95 2009 Hallmark Little Sweet Pea Baby’s First Christmas Special Edition Ornament
- $10.00 Hallmark Keepsake 2019 My First Christmas Jack In Box Bear Ornament NEW IN BOX
- $19.99 2022 Hallmark BABY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS BUGGY Stroller Pram Porcelain Ornament
- $11.99 2022 Hallmark Keepsake 2022 BABY GIRL'S FIRST CHRISTMAS Christmas Tree Ornament
- $16.75 Hallmark Baby Girl’s First Christmas 2022 Keepsake Ornament Dated
- $15.99 2016 Hallmark BABY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS Ornament NEW Shoes Booties PORCELAIN
- $17.99 Hallmark Ornament 2018 - Babys First Christmas Rattle Porcelain SEALED BOX, NIB
- $19.86 Baby's First Christmas Booties Porcelain 2021 Ornament
- $12.99 Hallmark 2022 BABY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS BUGGY Stroller Porcelain Ornament
- $12.99 2019 Hallmark Keepsake Baby Boy's First Christmas Blue Ornament Baby Shoe
- $14.99 2022 Hallmark BABY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS BUGGY Stroller Pram Porcelain Ornament
- $12.12 HALLMARK KEEPSAKE ORNAMENT 2008 LIVING ON BABY TIME ALARM CLOCK MAGIC WINDUP NIB
- $8.99 BABY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS STOCKING BLUE
- $9.04 Baby's First Christmas Winney The Pooh 18.5" Holiday Stocking NOS
- $8.99 BABY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS STOCKING PINK
- $17.99 Hallmark Keepsake 1995 Baby's First Christmas Baby's Silver Cup Tag Ornament
- $29.56 Hallmark Keepsake Ornament Babys First Christmas (1995)
- $12.74 2022 Hallmark Keepsake 2022 BABY GIRL'S FIRST CHRISTMAS Christmas Tree Ornament
- $29.99 Holiday Lane, Christmas Ornaments, Various to choose, NWT cb2
- $21.49 Hallmark 2011 Baby's First Christmas Porcelain Carriage Stroller Ornament New
- $38.69 2009 Hallmark Little Sweet Pea Baby’s First Christmas Ornament SPECIAL EDITION
- $13.49 NIB Lenox Elephant Baby’s First Christmas Ornament James 2016 PERSONALIZED
- $40.00 Christopher Radko Hush Little Baby Ornament 00-989-0
- $11.86 Hallmark 2022 BABY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS BUGGY Stroller Porcelain Ornament
- $3.99 Hallmark BABY BOY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS Blue Bear Booties Keepsake Ornament NEW
- $20.00 Baby’s First Christmas 4 Glass Ornaments 1st Vtg New Shower Gift Heart Bottle
- $34.99 4 Hallmark Baby Ornaments 2022 Babys First Christmas, Ultrasound, Boy Girl Birds
- $12.23 2022 HALLMARK KEEPSAKE BABY GIRL’S FIRST CHRISTMAS ORNAMENT (CB7102)
- $14.95 NEW 2022 Hallmark BABY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS BUGGY Stroller Porcelain Ornament T4
- $16.96 Winter Wonderland Baby First Christmas 2022 Blue Frame Ornamenr 2.5x4
- $24.99 Vintage 1995 Hallmark BABY'S FIRST 1st CHRISTMAS Teddy Bear in Tin Cup Ornament
- $14.00 Hallmark Keepsake 2019 Dated Baby Boy’s First Christmas Blue Teddy Booties
- $7.00 2019 Hallmark MY FIRST CHRISTMAS Ornament BABY FIRST Baby's 1st JACK IN BOX BEAR
- $6.99 2019 Hallmark Keepsake Baby Boy's First Christmas Blue Ornament Baby Shoe
- $7.47 Hallmark 2019 Baby Girl’s First Christmas Keepsake Ornament-NIB
- $19.99 Hallmark Ornament 2018 - Babys First Christmas Rattle - Porcelain
- $8.00 HALLMARK 2022 Baby Girl's First Christmas Ornament New in Box Pink Bird in Nest
- $6.99 2019 Hallmark BABY BOY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS Ornament 1st BLUE Teddy Bear Booties
- $7.10 Hallmark Ornament 2019 Baby Girl’s First Christmas Pink Teddy Bear Booties
- $10.00 Hallmark Keepsake 2019 My First Christmas Jack In Box Bear Ornament NEW IN BOX
- $10.00 Hallmark Keepsake Baby Boy's First Christmas Blue Booties 2019 Ornament NEW
- $14.99 VNTG 1980's Baby's First Christmas Stocking - Morehead,Inc. Toy Solider/Carousel
- $9.99 2019 Hallmark MY FIRST CHRISTMAS Ornament BABY FIRST Baby's 1st JACK IN BOX BEAR
- $13.00 Baby First 1st Christmas Pink Girl STOCKING New CHRISTMAS
- $13.99 2022 Hallmark Keepsake 2022 BABY GIRL'S FIRST CHRISTMAS Christmas Tree Ornament
- $15.00 Hallmark Keepsake 2019 Baby Boy's First Christmas Ornament Blue Bear Booties
- $29.99 Hallmark Keepsake Ornament 2011 Porcelain Baby's First Christmas NIB
- $4.99 Dept 56 SnowBabies Baby's MY FIRST STAR Icicle Christmas Ornament
- $35.00 New Special Edition Hallmark Little Sweet Pea Ornament African American 2009
- $13.39 My First Christmas Photo Ornament, Babys First Christmas Tree Ornament, Newbo...
- $4.99 Hallmark Keepsake 2019 My First Christmas Jack In Box Bear Ornament
- $10.00 2022 Hallmark BABY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS BUGGY Carriage Porcelain Ornament
- $24.99 Hallmark Keepsake Ornament 2019 Baby Boys First Christmas NIB
- $1.00 Hallmark Keepsake Ornament 2019 Baby Girl’s First Christmas Pink CLEARANCE SALE
- $12.00 BABY's FIRST CHRISTMAS STOCKING Blue Xmas Stocking 17" NOS
- $13.99 2016 Hallmark BABY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS Ornament PORCELAIN BABY BOOTIES
- $12.95 2022 Hallmark BABY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS BUGGY Stroller Pram Porcelain Ornament
- $19.99 Hallmark BABY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS BUGGY Stroller Porcelain Ornament 2022 NIB
- $9.99 Baby's First Christmas Pink Stocking Christmas
- $21.99 Baby'S First Christmas Ornaments Gifts 2023 1St Christmas Photo Ornaments for Ba
- $14.95 Hallmark Ornament 2016 "Baby's First Christmas" Porcelain Booties NEW
- $15.00 Waterford Crystal Marquis Baby's First Christmas 2008 Bear With Balloons - Boxed
- $24.99 Hallmark Keepsake Ornament 2019 My First Christmas NIB
- $19.99 HALLMARK 2020 Ornament Disney Minnie Mouse “BABY’S First Christmas” Photo Frame
- $21.99 Baby'S First Christmas Ornaments Gifts 2023 1St Christmas Photo Ornaments for Ba
- $13.99 Hallmark 2022 BABY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS BUGGY Stroller Porcelain Ornament 23-30
- $19.99 Hallmark Keepsake 2017 Grandbaby's 1st First Christmas Ornament Metal Cup NIB
- $24.99 Hallmark Keepsake Ornament 2019 Baby Girls First Christmas NIB
- $11.50 Hallmark Ornament Baby Boy's First Christmas Blue Porcelain Booties 2019 - NIB
- $13.99 HALLMARK BABY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS 2021 PHOTO ORNAMENT~DEBRA NIELSEN~NEW IN BOX
- $15.95 Kate & Milo My First Christmas Photo Ornament, Christmas Tree Ornament, Babys...
- $15.99 2017 Baby 1st Christmas Girl Photo Frame Harvey Lewis w/ Swarovski Crystals Pink
- $18.00 New Beacon 2019 Baby's First Christmas Ornament solid brass with 24 kt finish
- $18.99 2008 Hallmark LIVING ON BABY TIME Keepsake Ornament DIAPER TIME Sound & Motion
- $6.00 Dan Dee Holiday Time Baby's "My First Christmas" Red & White Stocking 11”x7”
- $19.99 2022 Dated Hallmark Baby Boy's First 1st Christmas Ornament Rattle Premium Metal
- $25.00 2 VTG Kurt S. Adler Holly Bearies Ornaments New Mommy & Daddy First Christmas
- $16.75 Hallmark Keepsake Ornament 2019 Year Dated Baby Girl’s First Christmas Pink