Advent Calendars
Candle Holders
Candles
Cards & Postcards
Christmas Trees
Costumes
Figurines
Incense Smokers
Lanterns
Lights
Masks
Nativity Items
Noisemakers
Nutcrackers
Ornaments
Other Holiday Collectibles
Props
Pyramids
Snow Globes
Stockings & Hangers
Table Décor & Serving Pieces
Tree Stands & Skirts
Tree Toppers
Villages & Houses
Wall Décor
Window Decorations
Wreaths, Garlands & Plants
Yard Décor
- $23.96 Baby's First Christmas Mementos Holiday Ornament Disney Winnie The Pooh Vintage
- $12.99 Vintage '80s Christmas Around the World ABC Ornaments Boxed Set of 3
- $235.00 JAY STRONGWATER BABY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS GLASS ORNAMENT #SDH2329-250 BRAND NIB F/S
- $25.00 VTG Dillards Trimmings Teddy Bear Baby’s First Christmas Ornament Holiday Decor
- $24.97 Baby's 1st First Christmas Hallmark Ornament 2017 Minnie Mouse Disney Holiday
- $9.89 Hallmark Keepsake Ornament "Baby's First Christmas" - Dated 1998 Train Holiday
- $4.99 NEW W/TAG *Boyds Bears 5.25" Lovable Teddy Bear ❤️
- $12.99 RUDOLPH RED NOSED REINDEER CLARICE BABY'S 1ST CHRISTMAS STOCKING BIB NEW NO HAT
- $9.98 BABY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS STOCKING HOLIDAY LIVING PINK GIRL'S BABY GIRL Girls
- $10.49 Gerson Int'l Silver Plated Holiday Ornament Baby's First Christmas Rattle Girl
- $24.99 Lenox 2017 Baby's First Christmas Holiday Rattle Ornament New In Box 1st Quality
- $15.49 Baby's First Christmas Keepsake Ornament Pewter Holiday Tree Charm Decoration
- $9.99 2000 Hallmark Keepsake Baby's First Christmas Stork Photo Holder Ornament - NEW
- $135.00 JAY STRONGWATER BABYS FIRST CHRISTMAS TEDDY GLASS ORNAMENT #SDH2044206 BNIB GIRL
- $13.95 Lenox Baby Jeweled Holiday 2006 Girl's Teething Ring, Booties, & Bling Ornament
- $14.99 Baby's First Christmas Plush Elephant Stocking Pink Girl Holiday 18.5''
- $3.99 Keepsake Ornament - Hallmark - Baby's First Christmas - Dated 2000 Train Holiday
- $18.73 The Original S'mores Midwest Brown Bear Baby's First Christmas Holiday Ornament
- $14.99 Holiday Place Set of 6 Blue & Pink Glass Baby's First Christmas Ornaments
- $22.41 Spode Tree Holiday Baby's 1st First Christmas Bootie 2023 Ornament New Box
- $10.49 Gerson Int'l Silver Plated Holiday Ornament Baby's First Christmas Bear Girl
- $12.99 Baby Boy's First Christmas Stocking Blue Teddy Bear Newborn Gift Holiday Cozy
- $17.99 Holiday Lane Baby’s First 2020, Fleece Polar Bear Baby Stocking in Blue
- $7.99 Hallmark Keepsake Grandchild's First Christmas Clip on Ornament MIB New 1994
- $10.99 NWT - " Baby's First Christmas " Stocking by Holiday Home, Green Felt Trim
- $14.99 NWT ROMAN, INC. "BABY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS" YELLOW DUCKLING ROMPER HOLIDAY ORNAMENT
- $11.95 Baby's My First Christmas Stocking with Reindeer Holiday Carter's Brand
- $11.99 NWT - Blue " Baby's First Christmas " Stocking, Soft Thick Plush by Holiday Home
- $17.33 Vintage Lenox Crystal Baby’s First Christmas Ornament 1990s Holiday Hanging
- $19.88 Baby's First Christmas Tree Ornaments Boy Blue Silver Pacifier Bottle Toys Duck
- $14.00 Baby's First Christmas XMAS Holiday Stocking Babies Children Boys Girls
- $12.00 Set of 7 Baby's First Christmas Holiday Tree Ornaments!
- $19.99 Hallmark Keepsake Baby’s First Christmas Girl Pink Booties Ornament 2002
- $16.99 Vintage 1984 Cabbage Patch Kids Stocking Holiday White Baby's First Christmas
- $10.00 Precious Moments 1992 You Brighten My Holidays Light Up Ornament 586412 NIB
- $9.98 BABY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS STOCKING HOLIDAY LIVING PINK BOY'S BABY BOYS
- $4.99 Peanuts Snoopy Woodstock Baby’s First Christmas Stocking Hat Set
- $10.00 Hallmark Babys First Christmas Ornament 1985 Carousel Bears Holiday Magic
- $9.99 Baby’s Print Ornament Kit Tiny Ideas New Open Box
- $20.00 Christmas Ball Ornament Hand Painted 2011 A Partidge A Pear Tree Holiday Decor
- $12.99 Personalized Babys First Christmas Ornament Elephant w/ Bell Holiday
- $12.50 Baby's First Christmas Knit Blue & Pink Stocking Holiday Russ Wooden Soldier EUC
- $24.00 Department 56 Snowbabies Sleepy Slumber, Baby's 1st Ornament 6012364 Dept Snowba
- $14.95 Baby's First Christmas Ceramic Cross Ornament - NIB
- $9.99 Wellington 13" Babys First Christmas Red White Holiday Baby Stocking
- $9.99 2014 Hallmark Keepsake African American Baby's First Christmas Ornament - NEW
- $6.99 Baby's First Christmas Stocking and Hat Dan Dee Snoopy Holiday NEW Peanuts
- $12.95 Hallmark Ornament Baby Boy's First Christmas 2014
- $2.00 BABY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS Bear on Wooden Block Holiday Ornament
- $11.11 Hallmark Keepsake Ornament - I Am One! Xmas 2016 NIB (Mm)
- $12.44 Campbell's Soup Kids Airplane Plane Ornament 1998 Holiday Christmas Vintage
- $6.45 Hallmark Little Hands Handprint Ornament Kit w/ Snowman design Keepsake Ornament
- $18.88 Hallmark Keepsake Baby's First Christmas Holiday Ornament Winnie The Pooh Family
- $7.99 1997 Hallmark African Baby's First Christmas Harlem Textile Works Ornament - NE
- $11.69 Holiday Lane Baby's First 2020 Fleece Polar Bear Baby Stocking in Blue
- $14.99 Harvey Lewis 2018 Reindeer Holiday Tree 2” Christmas Ornament
- $10.00 Hallmark Keepsake Baby's Open Me First" Christmas Holiday Clip On Ornament 1986
- $14.99 2023 Hallmark Grandbaby's First Christmas-Baby In Pea Pod Porcelain Ornament-NIB
- $8.95 Baby's First Christmas 13" Stockings Holiday Home Turquoise Pink Red Green
- $11.89 Hallmark Keepsake Ornament Babys 1st First Christmas Peppermint Express 2000
- $3.99 BABY'S FIRST 1ST CHRISTMAS 2019 HANGING 3D ORNAMENT HOLIDAY USA PR2319
- $14.99 Baby's First Christmas Stocking Blue Reindeer Holiday Home New W/ Tags
- $9.04 Baby's First Christmas Winney The Pooh 18.5" Holiday Stocking NOS
- $10.61 Cavanagh Holiday 2005 Baby First Christmas Bear Illuminated Glass Ball Ornament
- $14.99 Baby boy blue first holiday ornaments duck pacifier car shoe block bottle in box
- $29.99 Holiday Lane, Christmas Ornaments, Various to choose, NWT cb2
- $7.15 Russ Brand Baby's First Christmas Knit Blue & Pink Stocking Holiday
- $9.99 Hallmark Keepsake Ornament "Baby's First Christmas" - Dated 2002 EUC
- $42.99 Christopher Radko 1994 Stocking Full Blown Glass Silver Christmas Ornament Toys
- $10.00 Baby's First Christmas Holiday Rudolph The Red Nosed Reindeer 3 pc Set
- $16.99 Precious Moments BABY'S FIRST CHRISTMAS holiday ornament Bell Girl Bunny 4" tall
- $14.99 Gerson Int'l Sterling Holiday Ornament Baby's First Christmas Boy
- $8.05 Carter's Brand Baby's My First Christmas Stocking with Reindeer Holiday
- $18.99 Precious Moments Baby's First Christmas Ornament 125954 Holiday Espressions
- $12.99 Grandparent Gift Co Pewter Baby's First Christmas Holiday Ornament
- $10.99 Baby's First Christmas Holiday Pink Plush Snowman Sparkle Stocking 16"
- $40.00 Christopher Radko Hush Little Baby Ornament 00-989-0
- $7.00 Rudolph Red Nose & Clarice Babys First Christmas 3 Piece Set Hat Bib & Stocking
- $3.00 2003 Hallmark Primera Navidad de Bebé - Baby's First Christmas Keepsake Ornament
- $11.99 NWT - Pink " Baby's First Christmas " Stocking, Soft Thick Plush by Holiday Home
- $30.00 1995 Hallmark Ornament Baby's First Christmas Cup w/ Silver Tag for Engraving
- $8.75 Pig Lollipop Cookie Jar Candy Ornament by Lustre Fame Holiday Hat Vintage VTG
- $10.99 NWT - " Baby's First Christmas " Stocking by Holiday Home, Red Felt Trim
- $13.56 The JWM Collection Baby's First Christmas Blue Boy Holiday Ornaments
- $14.79 Bella Lux Glass Baby’s First Christmas Ornaments 2 Pack Holiday Gift 2019 Pink
- $11.95 My First Christmas Resin Photo Ornament Not Dated Holiday Nursery Rhyme Brand
- $13.95 Hallmark 1983 Keepsake Ornament - Baby's First Christmas Rocking Horse Cameo NIB
- $9.99 Lenox Baby Jewels Holiday Girl Ornament Silver Plate Diaper Pin Booties Charms
- $7.15 Baby Boy's First Christmas Stocking with Snowman Holiday Koala Kids Brand
- $10.95 Baby's First 16" Blue & Pink Knit Stocking Holiday
- $4.95 Baby's First Christmas Holiday Ornament Teddy Bear W/ Heart Photo Frame Blue Gem
- $10.00 Bella Lux Glass Baby’s First Christmas Ornaments 2 Pack Holiday Gift 2019 Blue
- $18.88 Hallmark Keepsake Baby's First Christmas Holiday Ornament Teddy Bear Shoe Family
- $7.50 Bella Lux Glass Baby’s First Christmas Ornaments 2 Pack Holiday Gift Pink
- $16.00 8 Vintage Rocking Horse LETTER A Wood Blocks Christmas Ornament Blue Pink Yellow
- $10.40 Campbell's Soup Kids Airplane Plane Ornament 1998 Holiday Christmas Vintage
- $12.50 REGENT SQUARE 2021 BABYS FIRST CHRISTMAS BOY'S SILVER PLATE ORNAMENT FRAME BLUE
- $11.95 Lenox Baby Jewels Holiday Boy Ornament Silver Plate Diaper Pin Heart Booties Box
- $12.99 2 Vintage Baby Bear on Wooden Block Holiday Christmas Ornaments Hand Painted
- $49.99 1982 Hallmark Keepsake Baby's First Christmas Boy Ball Ornament NIB NEW IN BOX