NOTE: When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission.
Learn more*
Best Match
Newest
Ending
Lowest Price
Highest Price
Best Match
Newest
Ending
Lowest Price
Highest Price
S
M
L
XL
Share
Share
Twitter
Facebook
Email
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$250.00
Rare 1930s Cattaraugus Cutlery Co Little Valley- 24399 Jigged Bone 2 Blade Knife
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$300.00
Rare 1930s Cattaraugus Cutlery Little Valley NY USA-Bone Handle Jumbo Jack Knife
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$250.00
Vintage 1920s Cattaraugus Little Valley NY Jigged Bone Handles -3 Blade Knife.
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$500.00
Early 1900's Cattaraugus Cutlery Co Little Valley, NY Floral Etched Pocket Knife
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$68.99
Vintage Cattaraugus Cutlery Little Valley, NY. Horn 2 Blade 3in. Pocket Knife
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$1000.00
VINTAGE PRE CASE XX 20s CATTARAUGUS SCOUT CAMP BONE POCKET KNIFE PAT 1115780 GG
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$50.00
Vintage Cattaraugus Cutlery Little Valley Double Blade Folding Pocket Knife #333
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$450.00
VINTAGE CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO. #12839 KING OF THE WOODS LOCKBACK HUNTER KNIFE
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$68.00
Cattaraugus Blue Chief Skinning Knife
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$125.00
Vintage Cattaraugus Fixed Blade Knife & Sheath Used But Good Condition
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$49.95
CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO LITTLE VALLEY NY 2 BLADE ZEBRA WOOD JACK KNIFE USE READY
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$69.95
CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO LITTLE VALLEY NY 3 BLADE YELLOW DELRIN WHITTLER KNIFE
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$169.00
Vintage CATTARAUGUS 225Q FIXED BLADE HUNTING KNIFE
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$115.00
Antique Early 1900s Pearl Handles Cattaraugus Little Valley,NY 2-Blade Knife
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$254.15
Vintage Cattaraugus English jack K.C.C. FH3 Japan Knife & original box 1990 RARE
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$99.99
Vintage Cattaraugus Brand 225Q WW2 Fighting Knife--250.24
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$285.00
💯1882-1930"s "None better" CATTERAUGUS BIG Worm Groove Bone RARE Knife
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$675.00
💯VINTAGE CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY CO. Big 5- 3/8" KING OF WOOD LOCKBACK HUNTER KNIFE
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$185.00
💯 Cattaraugus 4 bld. SUPER Rare WORM Groove BONE Beautiful Vintage knife
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$19.00
Vintage Cattaraugus Kitchen Knife Household Institute Better Brushes Sheath
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$20.00
VINTAGE CATTARAUGUS Cleaver, Chef, Butcher & Sandwich/Spreader/READ DETAILS
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$500.00
VINTAGE PRE CASE XX CATTARAUGUS LITTLE VALLEY CELLULOID WHITTLER FILE KNIFE GG
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$39.99
Cattaraugus Cutlery Company 11057 Hawkbill Pruner Hardwood Handled Pruning,
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$60.00
Vintage Cattaraugus Fixed Blade Sheath Knife Used But Good Condition
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$189.99
Vintage WW2 CATTARAUGUS 225Q Military Combat Knife Dagger & Leather Sheath
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$99.95
Rare Collector 4 Blade Cattaraugus Cleveland Trencher Advertising Pocket Knife
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$595.00
vintage Cattaragus HUNTING Fixed Blade Knife with Sheath better Quality Knife
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$32.39
USA VTG CATTARAUGUS UTILITY BONING FIXED BLADE KNIFE SHEATH ORANGE BROWN KITCHEN
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$64.99
Vintage Rare Cattaragus Electricans knife--3205.23
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$79.99
Vintage Early Cattaraugus Cutlery Co. Pen Knife Mother of Pearl handle--1107.23
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$229.99
Vintage Cattaraugus 225Q Fixed Blade Quartermaster Knife stacked leather handle
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$34.99
Vintage Cattaragus Fillet knife bakelite handle no sheath--2902.23
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$60.00
vintage cattaraugus fixed blade knife with sheath.
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$21.99
CATTARAUGUS KITCHEN CLEAVER KNIFE Brown Grip Handle Vtg Cutlery USA Cook Chef
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$29.95
Cattaraugus Fixed Blade Knife 7 1/8" Long Blade Flexible Prototype
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$250.00
Vintage Cattaraugus English jack K.C.C. FH3 Japan Knife & original box 1990 RARE
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$124.95
Vintage Cattaraugus WW2 Airmen Folding Survival Machete Knife USA
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$379.00
2 x EXCELSIOR Cattaraugus BONE 1989 WHITTLER $ Barlow Knives RARE! CM-14 CM-17 !
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$44.16
SALE Antique Cattaraugus Cutlery Co Mother Pearl 3 1/4" Knife Scissors CorkScrew
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$85.46
Vintage Cattaraugus Cutlery Co Little Valley NY 22299 Two Blade Stag Pocketknife
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$100.00
Antique CATTARAUGUS Little Valley, NY 2 Blade Folding Pocket Knife c1890
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$39.99
VINTAGE CATTARAUGUS VANADALOY CHEF BUTCHER CLEAVER CHROMED HC STEEL USA KNIFE
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$108.72
Cattaraugus WW2 Airmen Folding Survival Machete Knife USA World War II W/gaurd
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$189.99
NIB 1989 Cattarugus CM-14 Japan Pocket Knife Bone Handles 3 1/2" Closed Rare New
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$19.99
Vintage Cattaraugus Fishing Fillet Knife High Carbon Vanadium Steel Black Handle
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$65.00
CATTERAUGUS vintage HUNTING Fixed Blade Knife
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$17.00
Cattaraugus Cleaver White Bakelite Type Handle 4.5" Blade Nice
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$285.00
Antique Vintage 3093 CATTARAUGUS CUTLERY Co Folding GENTLEMAN'S MOP Pocket KNIFE
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$30.00
Cattaraugus Cuttlery Co New York Little Injun Serrated Kitchen Knife Vintage USA
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$39.99
Vintage Cattaraugus Cutlery Co Little Valley N.Y. Large 2-Blade Pocket Knife
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$59.99
Vintage Cattaraugus Vanadium Fixed Blade Knife + Leather Sheath
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$175.00
Vintage CATTARAUGUS Cutlery Co. Little Valley N.Y. Folding Pocket Knife
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$500.00
VINTAGE PRECASE XX CATTARAUGUS LITTLE VALLEY CELLULOID PEN 23224 POCKET KNIFE GG
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$200.00
NIB 1989 Cattarugus CM-14 Japan Pocket Knife Bone Handles 3 1/2" Closed Rare New
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$50.00
Vintage Cattaraugus Fixed Blade Butter? Knife Bone Stag Handle Carbon Steel USA
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$225.00
Vintage Cattaraugus electricians knife 1920-1940
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$55.00
RARE VINTAGE CATTARAUGUS COOKING KNIFE WOOD HANDLE Q463
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$59.00
Vintage Cattaraugus Fixed Blade Knife w/Stacked Leather Handle and Sheath
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$25.00
Vintage Cattaraugus Fishing Fillet Knife w/ Sheath Serrated
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$120.00
Vintage Western L-66 Knife And CATTARAUGUS MILITARY KNIFE/WW11 ERA/HUNTING
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$45.00
CATTARAUGUS KNIFE MADE IN USA #32403 VINTAGE FOLDING POCKET
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$129.00
CATTARAUGUS FH-1 G-inscribed Folding Knife w/Box. Japan . Working. Beautiful
Share
Pinterest
Facebook
Twitter
Email
$665.00
Cattaraugus 12829 King Of The Woods Folding Knife Pre 1906 Coca Cola Bottle
MORE